🔗 Share this article

“They tried to murder us. They were unsuccessful. Let’s dine,” remarked a community figure.

That age-old Jewish adage seems particularly pertinent in a northern English city during present-day threats.

For the councillor, the humorous remark captures the strong spirit that marks his observant Jewish neighbourhood.

This lively neighbourhood was targeted by an Islamic State undercover group, whose plan to “kill as many Jews as possible” in a rampaging gun incident was thwarted. Two individuals were sentenced this week on extremism charges.

Neighbourhood Solidarity and Daily Struggles

As stated by the councillor, the foiled scheme has not diminished the neighbourhood’s wish to coexist with its neighbours. “My business partner is a devout Muslim and we work well together,” said the financial advisor. “You find good and bad in any group. Most just want to live in peace.”

The extremists saw the Jewish population solely through the warped perspective of antisemitism.

They showed no interest in the diverse lifestyles, incomes, religious practice and political views within Greater Manchester’s Jewish populations, nor in the pressing issues like poverty that impact many British areas.

A local leader runs a children and families centre that aids hundreds of families, including large strictly observant families and some Muslim women. The hub offers mother and baby groups, clinics, advice services, educational programs, and crucial financial and material support.

“Outsiders think the biggest issue is safety – that’s rubbish,” she said. “Of course we’re sad and we reflect, but the women I work with are finding it hard to manage with day-to-day lives, stress and many children. We are here to help.”

“The cost of living – kosher food is very costly – utility costs, people who can’t afford basic essentials, housing, benefits issues – that’s what I’m focused on.”

Heightened Vigilance and Strong Spirit

Despite these challenges, two unifying themes have grown under strain. One is a marked shift “towards community solidarity and participation,” according to a recent community study organisation. The other is a culture of watchfulness on a level rare in most UK communities.

“We can respond to an situation in two minutes,” said the executive director of a Jewish neighbourhood watch group that shares intelligence with police.

“The feeling is certainly tense,” they added. “There has been a significant rise in reports to our 24-hour hotline about suspicious activities.”

Nonetheless, Walters stressed that the Orthodox communities, among the most rapidly expanding in Europe, did not live in terror. “We cherish life,” he said. “And we believe that if we pass away, we’re going to a better place. We choose not to be frightened.”

Wider Context and Calls for Action

Other senior community figures contend that considerably more must be done to confront the danger of Islamist extremism.

While statistics show that cases with clear right-wing extremist ideology exceeded those linked to Islamist extremism last year, the most lethal plots in recent years have been perpetrated by individuals inspired by extremist ideology.

“A major part of our work on the safety side is trying to detect and prevent hostile surveillance of Jewish sites that would precede an attack,” said a security director from a community security organisation.

They noted a pattern of terrorism and anti-Jewish activity coming from suburbs north of the city, leading to questions about the particular dynamics in that region.

Recent attacks abroad have occurred with Jewish festivals and anniversaries, heightening a sense of worldwide unease.

Assessment on a Shifting Paradigm

Some commentators argue that a postwar assumption has shifted.

“From a British perspective, there was an view there was a golden age in terms of post-Holocaust understanding of what anti-Jewish hatred is,” said a spokesperson for a Jewish leadership council. “I think that perspective is starting to be seen as far too optimistic.”

They continued, “This is not to say we think this time is any more risky than any of those times before, but that there’s no assumption that troubled times won’t come back.”

There is acknowledgement of the endeavours being done within Islamic communities to dispute extremist narratives, though mainstream voices can feel overwhelmed.

Calls have been made for the authorities to bring forward a new radicalism framework, with an emphasis on addressing the ideological threat presented by radical views, distinct from faith or individuals.

Defiance and Hope

However, despite the context of safety concerns, a note of joyful resilience characterises even solemn occasions.

“At a recent gathering to mark an solemn date, the discussion turned to the Manchester attack,” a leader recounted. “Unexpectedly, at the end, a musician started playing Jewish tunes and people started celebrating. That’s the hopeful side.”

“But I would be dishonest if I said those grave debates about the prospects of Jewish life in this nation haven’t been continuing.”